Evangelicals are the Most Powerful Religious Group in America

Phil Mitchell • November 16, 2026

New Title


There is lots being written these days about religion in America and inevitably the question is asked what is the most powerful religious group? In a recent Free Press article Ross Douthat, a believing Catholic, said, “The form of Christianity that’s most adapted to late-modern America is clearly not the Church of Rome. It’s evangelical Protestantism.” I agree with Douthat. I think the Evangelicals compose America’s most powerful religious group. But let me add a number of considerations.


A person is an Evangelical if they believe two things. One, the Bible is their final authority. It’s not some kind of Pope nor is it a church council or a hierarchy of clergy. It is the Bible alone and each person is left to interpret it for himself. Second, a person becomes a Christian instantaneously as a result of a decision to trust Christ as Savior. I realize not every Christian can tell you the moment they were saved but the Bible clearly teaches you go from death to life in a moment of saving faith. The opposite of this is the sacramental system whereas you are saved by installments. You become a Christian by degrees through partaking of certain church rituals. This is not evangelicalism.


By the above definition a lot of people are Evangelicals. Most Protestants—including big groups like Baptists, Pentecostals, and Charismatics. A small number of Catholics and even a small number of Mormons hold to Evangelical Christianity in spite of their church’s doctrines, as do many members of the mainline, oldline protestant denominations. Almost all non-denominational churches are Evangelical and virtually all megachurches—congregations of more than 2,000 on a Sunday morning.


The British missions publication Operation World puts the number of American Evangelicals at over 100 million. Pew Research says it’s 78 million. By any definition Evangelicals form the largest religious group in America.

 

Of course, numbers alone don’t equal power. And in a number of ways Evangelicals do not wield power in America. There are few of us in the citadels of elite power. Few in Hollywood, essentially none in the academic community where we are denied entry by entrenched religious bigotry. Only a small number in corporate boardrooms or government bureaucracies are populated by Evangelicals. Roman Catholics would criticize my arguments by saying Evangelicals carry little influence among public intellectuals and that is surely a fair criticism.


But Evangelicals are powerful in the ways we care about.  We are great at creating community—the best in the whole world at this. For the great masses of Gen Xers and millennials hungering for a place to belong we do a great job of providing one. 


Evangelicals supply tens of thousands of congregations with great preaching. The ability to communicate from the pulpit is demanded by Evangelicals and thousands of Evangelical pastors are talented pulpit communicators and command followings in the tens of millions. Evangelicalism trains young men to be talented communicators and they are. Preaching is very good even in the average church and ranges from great to brilliant in the larger churches. 


Evangelicals perform great works of service. I read some time ago that there are three rescue missions in downtown Salt Lake City ministering to primarily Mormon alcoholics and drug addicts. All are Evangelical. Every big city in America has an Evangelical rescue mission. Thousands and thousands of recovery groups are started and run by Evangelicals as are ministries in jails and prisons.

Evangelicals run food banks that feed multitudes, they provide clothing closets for the needy and there are thousands of food drives every holiday run by Evangelicals. Ever hear of the Salvation Army? The Army is Evangelical to the core.


Evangelicals are faithful to their name and are intensely evangelistic at the grassroots level. American Evangelicals are the most missionary minded people in world history. We send out north of a hundred thousand missionaries to the rest of the world. And the results: Christianity is exploding in many places around the globe.


The Evangelical church is the most family friendly venue in western culture. We have more children than other groups.  We are by far the most welcoming venue for young men. We don’t brand them as toxic. We equip them to build families and communities and they are responding to our message as never before.


The Roman Catholic church has more visibility in the public debate about culture but remember—the Catholics care about that. The vast majority of Protestants don’t care if Hollywood touts our culture our if university faculty lounges view us with respect. We go about our business at the at the level where people live.

There are some fair criticisms of Evangelicals but most are ridiculous. As a group Evangelicals have no interest in taking over the American government and imposing our religion on everyone else. It’s the Marxist Progressives and the Greens that do that.   Racist? Tens of millions of people of color are Evangelicals. 

In the last fifty years both mainline Protestantism and Roman Catholicism have seen marked decline. But not so Evangelicals. We have held steady and are poised to become an even larger portion of the body politic.


In all the ways that matter Evangelicals are a powerful religious force, at the grassroots level the most powerful in America. For this we give God the glory. May He continue to bless us.



More: Why do Evangelicals vote Republican? https://studio.youtube.com/video/nrhBqmx_eCQ/edit

Timon Cline’s article: https://firstthings.com/a-catholic-moment-or-an-evangelical-century/

Contrary to online chatter, we are not in a “Catholic moment.” But we may already be in an evangelical century. 

Significantly more people are leaving Catholicism than converting to it. By contrast, evangelical Protestants boast remarkably high conversion and retention rates and healthier levels of practical piety—church attendance, Bible reading, catechesis. 

To cite one example, the percentage of Americans who convert from Catholicism to Protestantism (4 percent) is higher than the percentage of all converts to Catholicism (1.5 percent).

Insofar as our politics are theologically inflected, it is broad, nondenominational evangelicalism that informs the sociopolitical imagination. 

Douthat: https://www.thefp.com/p/ross-douthat-our-evangelical-era-christianity-catholic-protestant?utm_source=google&utm_medium=paid-search&utm_campaign=dsa&utm_adgroup=all&utm_term=&utm_matchtype=&gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=24256022137&gbraid=0AAAAApHxamFmrnRq4UJaj31VT2JSFLFR8&gclid=CjwKCAjwgJHXBhBGEiwAHohJq0kt9eOEVNMYKdyQggYuwcBPoJpnIhmYAVdlh1x7dC3Lt66T-fF_DBoCWwAQAvD_BwE

And in the wider culture, the form of Christianity that’s most adapted to late-modern America is clearly not the Church of Rome. It’s evangelical Protestantism. The vibes of a Catholic moment are real enough, but evangelicalism’s resilience is our era’s more fundamental fact.

Evangelicalism doesn’t just win more converts than Catholicism; it also keeps more of its young people in the faith.

 

Carl Trueman: Does Evangelicalism even exist? https://www.christianpost.com/voices/does-evangelicalism-really-exist.html?utm_source=insider.christianpost.com&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_campaign=test-b-new-template-cp-daily-nov-5-2026&_bhlid=f5bc1c3e5cd013cd85fdeaebb30706eb68b84394

 


401st Prophet Blog

By Phil Mitchell • October 30, 2026
The power of Christian Ideas
By Phil Mitchell • October 23, 2026
How will it impact Western culture?
By Phil Mitchell • October 14, 2026
Socialism is a Lie
By Phil Mitchell • October 3, 2026
Religion determines what kind of person you are
By Phil Mitchell • September 26, 2026
Terrorism
By Matt Sieger • September 23, 2026
God's Remarkable Creativity
By Phil Mitchell • September 19, 2026
Where do the greatest ideas in history come from?
By Phil Mitchell • September 14, 2026
Almost all religions teach you are saved through your own efforts.
By Phil Mitchell • August 27, 2026
The answer to declining population is spiritual.
By Phil Mitchell • August 22, 2026
Alternative family arrangements are a disservice to kids.